Rebecca White MHA and Bill Dermody being recorded by WIN TV

Health petitioners ‘ignored’ after signing the wrong side

THE State Government has been urged to respect the views of 1400 petitioners who were disenfranchised by a strict interpretation of the rules about petitions. New Norfolk’s Bill Dermody collected signatures from 2200 people concerned about health services in the Derwent Valley, but was told only 880 were valid.

Visiting New Norfolk earlier in the week, State Opposition Leader Rebecca White said residents were rightfully concerned about access to a doctor or after-hours health care in the district. “With the retirement of two long-standing local doctors almost a year ago, some Derwent Valley residents are still waiting to get on the books with local GPs,” Ms White said.

“In some cases, Derwent Valley residents have been forced to travel to Sandy Bay, Sorell and Brighton to get an appointment or to make sure they can get their prescriptions for medication. People in rural and regional areas deserve access to timely and local health services but are continually treated with contempt by the Liberal government.”

Mr Dermody told New Norfolk and Derwent Valley News that people had gone out of their way to sign his petition calling on the State Government to introduce nurse practitioners at the New Norfolk District Hospital and to lobby the Federal Government to change New Norfolk’s Medicare classification in order to attract and retain additional doctors to the town.

Mr Dermody said the petition had been signed by 2200 people, but only those on the front of each page were accepted as valid. “They didn’t accept those on the back of each sheet because it did not contain the details of the petition,” he said. “People went out of their way to sign it and those people should be recognised.”

At New Norfolk on Tuesday morning, Ms White said it was no surprise that people in the Derwent Valley had been forced to take matters into their own hands via the petition. “Yet instead of taking these concerns seriously the government has continued to ignore residents’ concerns,” Ms White said.

“The government’s response to the petition was to tell residents that they have ‘an appropriate level of access to out of hours care through the New Norfolk Ambulance Tasmania service’. This is completely out of touch – the ambulance station is dependent on volunteers to fully staff the roster and in some cases cannot open because there isn’t anyone available,” she said.

“A lack of access to GPs and community-based care contributes to added pressure on the hospital system because people can’t access the care they need to stay well. Labor understands the importance of making sure people have access to health care when and where they need it and will continue to call for better regional health services for the Derwent Valley and other regions across Tasmania.”

In a formal response, the State Government said it had already boosted services at the New Norfolk Hospital, including a full-time nurse practitioner to support patient management. Health Minister Sarah Courtney acknowledged that New Norfolk had the same Medicare classification as Hobart. “The Department of Health advises there is little opportunity for the Tasmanian Government to advocate for a change to New Norfolk’s classification due to its proximity to Hobart and service demand,” Ms Courtney said.

Mr Dermody said he had sought meetings with Ms Courtney and Liberal Lyons MHAs without success.


  1. Let us think about how fortunate we are to have local print media. I’m saying this because of the balanced nature of the reporting. The inclusion of both sides & the introduction of truth & facts is top-shelf.

    I’m submitting this analysis by way of observation & comment. Before starting I will be following up on “continually treated with contempt.” The contempt word originated in 1393, from the Latin word contempt us meaning “scorn”. In plain talk the feeling that a person or a thing is worthless or beneath consideration. I would like to hear from readers about that.

    Our community now has before us the result of a people-power process. The cornerstone of this process is to follow the rules. In the first instances, comply with the number for a valid petition. Therefore this petition is “disenfranchised by a strict interpretation of the rules about petitions”

    On another front is the rules that are applied by the federal level of government, and thirdly by the rules/protocols about the influence that the State Government has in making our case to the Federal Government.

    The response from the Government appeared to hit all the bases. This will be a very difficult one from the political perspective to hit a home run. Of course our council could involve the Senators i.e. “a change to New Norfolk’s classification.”

  2. Liberal Government disenfranchising DV voters? Surely they should be supporting the people whose will was clear.
    Stop looking for wiggle words to avoid your responsibilities.

  3. The fact that parliament would only accept 840 of the votes, doesn’t reduce the fact that over 2,200 people, from the Derwent Valley, went out of their way to sign the petition because, it was calling on state parliament to address what is a major issue impacting the Derwent Valley/Central Highlands communities being, people having to wait anywhere from 2 to 6 weeks to see a GP, that there are no after hours/weekend medical services in the Derwent Valley/Central Highlands communities, people are unable to present at the New Norfolk Hospital and therefore have no alternative but to wait for weeks to see a GP or present at the RHH ED or call an ambulance and as there are so few after hors/weekend Medical/Health services in regional areas, is one of the main circumstances leading to Ambulance ramping and people waiting hours for and Ambulance. During this process. I sent a number of e-mails to Sarah Courtney and Guy Barnett requesting an opportunity to meet and discuss the issues to which I only receive an acknowledgement of receipt of the e-mail from the Health Minister and no response from minister Barnett. this shows a lack of respect to the community and no willingness to listen to the concerns re these major issues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Share on facebook
Share on email
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Local Weather

COVID-19 Advice and Links

Latest headlines

Filter by topic

New Norfolk News Archive

RSS Tas articles feed